Analysis of business results & financial statements · Quý 3/2024
▼▼ Declining sharply
Trailing net profit reached 23.9bn, rose 4.1bn compared with the same period last year. Key positives came from lower selling expenses, lower administrative expenses, and lower finance costs. Offsetting pressure came mainly from lower gross profit. Detailed impact is shown below:
See what is changing ↓- P/E
- -0.60x
- P/B
- 0.57x
- EPS
- -2,991
- BVPS
- 3,183
- ROE
- -63.9%
- ROA
- -14.2%
- Market price
- 1,800 16 Oct 2026
The current picture
What Is Changing
On a TTM 2024Q3 basis, VTA is under pressure on both revenue and margins simultaneously — profit momentum has been slowing across consecutive periods. More notably, operating cash flow is significantly negative relative to profit — this is pressure that needs close monitoring.
Profit bridge
Vs last year · TTM
- Selling expenses
- Administrative expenses
- Finance costs
- Gross profit
Across periods
A single data point, or a trajectory?
Latest eight quarters · Quý 3/2024
| Metric | Q3'24 | Q2'24 | Q1'24 | Q4'23 | Q3'23 | Q2'23 | Q1'23 | Q4'22 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 20.4 | 26.9 | 28.7 | 29.0 | 32.9 | 46.3 | 44.1 | 59.6 |
| LNST | -4.0 | -6.5 | -4.1 | -9.3 | -6.0 | -9.0 | -4.2 | -8.8 |
| Net margin | -19.87% | -24.06% | -14.26% | -32.13% | -18.28% | -19.48% | -9.46% | -14.81% |
Revenue
20bnNet income
-4bnNet margin
-19.87%Inside the statements
A closer look at what is happening inside the business
A company's statements are read with the questions that fit its type of business.
Is the profit sustainable?
Margins narrowed but earnings quality remains clean — pressure is mainly operational.
Revenue Growth
▼▼Is growth real and durable?
Trailing-12-month revenue declined 42.6% year on year — not from a single spike: quarterly growth stepped up from −51% to −38%.
0 of the last 4 quarters grew year on year.
- Revenue TTM
- 105bn −42.6%
- Latest quarter YoY
- −38% accelerating
What is driving the margin?
▼▼Net margin fell to −22.80%, losing 7.5pp. The main pressure comes from Gross margin fell 6.1pp and SG&A / Revenue rose 0.8pp (with lingering pressure from Net financial result / Revenue fell 0.5pp).
The pressure comes from core operations — this is a concerning type of decline, not a one-off movement.
- Net Margin
- −22.80% −7.5pp
- Gross Margin
- −10.68% −6.1pp
- SG&A / Revenue
- 9.53% +0.9pp
TTM YoY · 2023Q3 -> 2024Q3
Cash Flow
●Is profit converting into cash?
Leverage needs watching — cash flow shows the ability to service debt from operations. Operating cash flow reached 9.9bn against investing cash flow of 8.3bn (annual cash-flow figures for 2025).
Post-investment cash flow was positive +18.2bn. Financing cash flow was negative +22.7bn.
CFO / net income was −0,51 lần.
Track how much investment can be funded internally from operating cash flow.
Cash capex or FCF data is incomplete, so the cash-conversion view is only partial.
Earnings Quality
●How much income is non-core?
Non-core income makes up 11.3% of pre-tax profit — worth monitoring.
Within that, net financial result at +10.8%, other profit at +0.6% of PBT.
- Non-core / PBT
- 11.3% moderate
- Net financial / PBT
- 10.8%
- Other profit / PBT
- 0.6%
Is capital being used efficiently?
Capital efficiency is declining — check whether the drag is from margins or turnover.
Is capital being deployed efficiently?
▼▼ROIC fell to −27.09%, losing 2.6pp. That translates to −27.09 in after-tax operating profit for every 100 units of operating capital. Both NOPAT margin narrowed 7.5pp and capital turnover fell 0.42x, with invested capital holding roughly steady — pressure came from both operational efficiency and asset efficiency.
Both margin and turnover weakened — this is a broad-based decline, and cyclical versus structural components need to be separated.
ROIC is currently −27.09% — below the typical cost-of-capital threshold; worth tracking whether upcoming periods can rise above this level.
Working Capital Efficiency
▼Rising inventory is showing up in a longer cash cycle. Cash conversion cycle lengthened by 26.6 days versus the same period last year. The main moves came from DIO rose 72.4 days, DSO rose 7.0 days, and DPO rose 52.8 days.
Working capital cycle lengthened mainly due to slower inventory turnover — more capital is being tied up in inventory.
CCC stands at 137.6 days, suggesting that working capital remains tied up for a relatively long operating cycle.
DSO increased by +7.0 days, pointing to slower receivables turnover.
DuPont
What drives ROE?
ROE fell from −44.2% to −63.9% — dragged by net margin and asset turnover.
Is financial risk significant?
Check leverage, liquidity, and cash-flow conversion.
Leverage & Liquidity
▼▼Leverage warrants monitoring, with net debt / equity at 1.92x and interest coverage only at −8.53x.
At present, short-term debt accounts for 96.2% of total debt, cash equals 0.7% of debt, and total debt stands at 49.1bn.
- Net Debt / Equity
- 1.92x +0.86x
- Interest Coverage
- −8.53x −0.98x
- Cash / Debt
- 0.7% −0.9pp
- Short-term Debt / Total Debt
- 96.2% +1.4pp
TTM YoY · 2023Q3 -> 2024Q3
Net debt / equity stands at 1.92x, increasing balance-sheet pressure.
Interest coverage is −8.53x, leaving limited room to absorb financing costs.
Balance Sheet
●The balance sheet shows capital-allocation efficiency slipping. Leverage is elevated, requiring monitoring — liabilities at -5.17x equity, net debt at 1.92x equity.
Construction materials are input-cost-cycle businesses — gross margin is the thermometer. Input costs are eating the margin: gross margin narrowed 6.1pp YoY to −10.68% (TTM). Margin flexing with the raw-material cycle is a group property — the next question is how much high-cost inventory remains.
Gross margin (TTM): −10.68% · YoY -6.1pp
Inventory 78.0bn — 51.25% of total assets, above the materials-group median (13.00%); ≈ 245 days of sales.
Inventory / assets: 51.25% (group median 13.00%)
Days inventory outstanding: 245
None
Over the last 12 months, working capital released 36.0bn of cash, mainly thanks to lower inventories. Pressure from higher receivables and lower payables only partly offset that benefit.
In summary
Research synthesis
What this reporting period is showing
The business is showing a few weaker signals, but the current magnitude is not yet clear enough to conclude that this is a broader weakening phase. The next item to monitor is effective tax rate looks unusual, with effective tax rate at 0.0%. The main risk still sits in core profitability, with net margin down 7.5 pp.
- Watchpoint: the effective tax rate looks unusual, so current net profit may not fully reflect underlying earnings quality.
- Key risk: profitability remains under pressure, with trailing-12M net margin at -22.80% after a 7.5pp decline versus the same period last year.
What to verify next
Questions for the next period
Whether revenue stabilizes after a −42,6% YoY decline or keeps falling.
Whether margins hold around the current -22.80% level or narrow again.
Whether operating cash flow holds its 9.9bn (cumulative for 2025) level in upcoming periods or weakens.
From one stock to the whole portfolio
Where does this stock stand
among the rest of your investments?
Each stock is only one part of the wider picture. Looking at investments side by side makes their contribution, risks and opportunities across the portfolio clearer.
How much does this stock
contribute to the portfolio?
Its weight and influence across the assets held for investment.
Is the portfolio
well balanced?
How holdings, sectors and asset groups are distributed in relation to overall risk.
What other opportunities
or risks may be present?
What becomes visible only when investments are viewed together rather than one ticker at a time.